Common Mistakes Growing Herbs Indoors (+ How to Fix Them! 2025)

This site is supported by our readers. We may earn a commission, at no cost to you, if you purchase through links.

You’re likely making common mistakes growing herbs indoors that kill even the hardiest plants. Most people choose sun-loving herbs like rosemary for dark kitchens, cram them into tiny pots without drainage, and drown them with good intentions.

Then there’s the lighting disaster—thinking a windowsill gets enough light when your herbs are basically living in a cave. Poor soil that turns into concrete doesn’t help either.

The watering game becomes a guessing match between bone-dry and swamp-like conditions. These aren’t character flaws; they’re fixable technique issues that even experienced outdoor gardeners stumble over when moving inside, dealing with common mistakes that affect the growth of herbs.

Choosing Wrong Herbs

Choosing the wrong herbs is often where your indoor garden dreams start to wilt before they even begin.

You might pick high-maintenance varieties that demand more light and care than your home can provide, or select fast-growing herbs that quickly outgrow their containers and crowd out everything else, leading to a situation where your garden dreams start to fail.

Selecting Herbs That Require High Light

Why do so many indoor herb gardens fail? Often, it’s because gardeners choose light-loving herbs without realizing their intense sunlight needs.

High-light herbs like basil, rosemary, and oregano demand six to eight hours of direct sunlight daily—something most indoor spaces can’t provide.

The Fix: Position these herbs at south-facing windows or invest in full-spectrum LED grow lights. Place lights 12-14 inches above plants for 12-14 hours daily.

Monitor for pale leaves or stretched stems—clear signs of insufficient lighting. To maximize growth, consider using well-drained potting mix. Consider grouping light-loving herbs together near your brightest window, and supplement with artificial lighting during shorter winter days.

Picking Herbs That Are Challenging to Grow Indoors

You’re making herb species selection harder than it needs to be.

Rosemary struggles with low indoor humidity, while basil becomes leggy without bright light. Lavender’s the trickiest – it demands full sun and perfect drainage that’s tough to replicate indoors.

Cilantro, dill, and parsley often fail from insufficient light. These difficult species create beginner mistakes that lead to frustration.

Choose easier herb varieties like mint or chives instead. Overwatering, however, can also be fatal to herbs grown indoors, particularly in winter, which is a critical issue to avoid.

Not Considering Herb Growth Rates and Sizes

Overlooking mature size leads to overcrowded disasters in container gardening.

Fast-growing herbs like basil can quickly dominate smaller companions, while space-hungry mint spreads aggressively.

Without considering growth habits and pruning needs, your indoor herb garden becomes a tangled mess.

Plan spacing requirements from the start—your future self will thank you when harvesting!

Incorrect Pot Sizes

Choosing the right pot size makes all the difference between thriving herbs and struggling plants that never reach their potential.

Many gardeners unknowingly sabotage their indoor herb gardens by selecting containers that are too small, lack proper drainage, or don’t provide enough room for healthy root development and plant spread.

Using Pots That Are Too Small for Root Growth

Cramming herb roots into tiny containers is like trying to squeeze into shoes two sizes too small.

When plant roots become rootbound, they can’t absorb nutrients properly, leading to stunted plant size and watering imbalance issues.

Your herbs end up stressed and weak.

Choose pot size that’s 1.5-2 times larger than the root ball, and consider container material impact on growth.

Watch for roots circling the bottom—that’s your cue for repotting.

Not Providing Enough Space for Herbs to Spread

When you’re cramming multiple herbs into a single container, you’re setting them up for failure. Each herb needs adequate space to develop its root system and spread naturally.

Overcrowding leads to competition for nutrients, stunted growth, and increased pest problems. Your plants become rootbound quickly, requiring frequent repotting.

Consider adequate container dimensions for ideal growth. Give each herb its own container or use a much larger pot with proper plant spacing to prevent growth restriction and ensure they have enough room to thrive.

Choosing Pots Without Proper Drainage Holes

Why sacrifice your herbs to waterlogged misery? Poor drainage transforms your indoor herb gardening dreams into soggy nightmares, causing root suffocation and water pooling that kills plants faster than neglect.

Proper drainage holes prevent the indoor herb mistakes that doom most container gardens; similarly, failing to mulch outdoor gardens can lead to moisture loss.

Wrong Soil Mixtures

Your soil choice can make or break your indoor herb garden before you even plant your first seed.

Most gardeners grab whatever potting mix is on sale, but herbs need specific soil conditions to develop their full flavor and avoid common problems like root rot or nutrient deficiencies.

Herbs need these conditions to thrive, and without them, they may not develop their full potential, which can be a result of common problems.

Using Soil With Poor Drainage and Aeration

Dense, clay-like soils create the perfect storm for indoor herb gardening disasters.

Dense soil acts like a prison cell for your herb roots, trapping them in soggy, airless conditions.

You’ll trap roots in waterlogged conditions, causing soil compaction and root suffocation that kills plants quickly.

Garden soil or heavy potting mixes lack proper drainage solutions and aeration methods your herbs desperately need.

Fix this by adding perlite, coarse sand, and compost as soil amendments to improve indoor herb drainage and prevent common indoor herb mistakes.

Many gardeners also source specialized herb amendments for ideal growth.

This approach helps to avoid the pitfalls of indoor herb gardening, ensuring a healthier and more thriving herb garden by using the right drainage solutions.

Not Adding Essential Nutrients and Organic Matter

Poor soil fertility stunts your herb garden’s potential.

Many indoor gardeners skip adding organic compost, creating nutrient-deficient growing environments that cause yellowing leaves and weak growth.

Organic material enriches soil nutrients naturally, while organic fertilizer prevents over-fertilization that burns delicate roots.

Without proper compost, you’re basically starving your plants.

Using green manures can also improve nutrient cycling and is a key part of maintaining healthy soil, which is essential for a thriving herb garden with delicate roots.

Ignoring Soil PH Levels and Their Impact on Herbs

Many indoor gardeners overlook soil pH, yet ideal pH between 6.0-7.0 determines nutrient availability for your herbs.

Ignoring soil acidity creates nutrient lockout, causing yellowing leaves and stunted growth despite proper watering and lighting.

• Testing strips revealing your soil’s true pH numbers
• Lime powder brightening acidic soil for better herb health
• Sulfur amendments lowering alkaline soil naturally
• pH meters providing instant, accurate soil readings
• Herbs thriving with vibrant green leaves in balanced soil

This common mistake affects soil nutrients more than most realize. Regular pH testing prevents indoor herb problems before they start.

Inadequate Lighting

Light is the lifeline of your indoor herb garden, yet it’s where most people stumble.

Without adequate light, your herbs will stretch toward windows like desperate sunbathers, developing weak stems and pale leaves that taste about as flavorful as cardboard.

Not Providing Enough Natural Light for Herbs

Most herbs need six to eight hours of bright sunlight daily, but insufficient light creates weak, leggy growth that kills flavor.

Window placement matters—south-facing spots work best for sunlight requirements.

Light deprivation causes pale leaves and poor indoor herb light conditions. Your herbs stretch toward available light, creating that telltale leggy appearance when sunlight exposure falls short of their needs, resulting in weak and flavor-less herbs due to insufficient light.

Using Incorrect Artificial Lighting Spectrums and Intensities

When you switch to artificial indoor herb light, spectrum impact and intensity levels make or break your harvest.

Wrong LED selection creates weak, flavorless herbs—too much red light produces leggy stems, while excessive blue stunts essential oil production.

Plant placement within 6-12 inches helps guarantee proper light duration effectiveness.

Grow lights requiring 300-600 μmol/m²·s intensity prevent insufficient light issues, meeting your herbs’ light requirements better than inadequate sunlight exposure.

Understanding specific light wavelengths is vital for ideal growth.

Not Supplementing Natural Light With Grow Lights

Even with south-facing windows, insufficient light often hampers indoor herb growth during winter months.

Supplemental lighting using LED grow lights with proper light spectrum guarantees your herbs receive adequate photons year-round.

Position grow lights 6-12 inches above plants, use timer automation for consistent photoperiods, and choose energy-efficient LEDs to minimize consumption while maximizing herb light requirements.

For maximum growth, make certain you’re providing the correct light intensity levels.

Poor Watering Techniques

Water problems kill more indoor herbs than any other issue, yet most gardeners don’t realize they’re making these critical mistakes.

Your indoor herb garden’s success hangs by a thread—one watering mistake away from disaster.

You’re either drowning your herbs with too much love or starving them with neglect, and both approaches lead to the same disappointing result, which is often due to critical mistakes.

Overwatering and Causing Root Rot and Fungal Diseases

You’re drowning your herbs in kindness, but too much water kills faster than drought. Overwatering creates soggy soil that suffocates roots and invites fungal diseases like unwelcome dinner guests.

Fungal Control starts with smart watering techniques that prevent waterlogged conditions.

Underwatering and Causing Wilting and Stunted Growth

While overwatering kills herbs with soggy conditions, the opposite extreme proves equally damaging.

Underwatering leaves your herbs displaying telltale Wilting Symptoms like droopy leaves and stunted growth.

When soil moisture drops too low, root health suffers dramatically, and dry soil prevents nutrient uptake, causing wilted leaves that signal distress.

You’ll notice reduced Watering Frequency leads to slower development and poor yields from stressed plants.

Not Monitoring Soil Moisture and Adjusting Watering Schedules

Without tracking soil moisture levels and watering frequency, you’re basically flying blind with your herb care.

Check soil dryness by inserting your finger 2-3 inches deep—if it’s dry, it’s time to water.

This simple habit prevents both overwatering and underwatering, protecting against root rot while avoiding wilting signs and ensuring proper drainage importance.

Consider mulching for moisture to further regulate soil conditions, which is crucial for successful vegetable garden watering.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)